HOME
  ABOUT SOTOS LLP
  FRANCHISE SERVICES
  INDUSTRY EXPERTISE
  CLIENT SUCCESSES
  OUR LAWYERS
  PRACTICE AREAS
  OF INTEREST
  HELPFUL HINTS
  CAREERS
  CONTACT US
Affidavits of Documents

How To Be a Trial Witness

Pre-trial Conferences
 

Affidavits of Documents
Every party to a lawsuit must prepare an Affidavit of Documents. The preparation of the Affidavit of Documents is a joint effort between the client and the lawyer. This memo is designed to assist you in providing us with all of the documents needed to prepare a complete and accurate Affidavit of Documents.

The Affidavit must contain the following:







A list of all documents that you have in your possession or control that relate to the action. A document is in your 'control' if you can obtain it and the adverse party in the lawsuit cannot.
A list of all documents that relate to the action that you object to producing on the grounds of a legally recognized privilege. These documents are listed separately from the ones above and are not shown to the other side.
A list of all documents that relate to the action but which you no longer have in your possession and the reason you no longer have them (i.e. they were lost or destroyed).

A ‘document’ is anything that contains information relevant to the action. It can be a note, memorandum, letter, business card, contract, photograph, computer disk, etc. The list of what constitutes a document is very wide. If you are in doubt, bring the document to the attention of your lawyer anyway.

It is important to note that the term ‘all documents that relate to the action’ is not restricted to documents that you feel help your case. It includes everything that is relevant, whether it is helpful or damaging.

There are certain sanctions that result when a party fails to make full disclosure of all documents. The court may dismiss your action, strike out your pleading, or revoke or suspend your right to initiate or continue an examination for discovery.

There are other penalties for trying to use a document at trial that was not previously disclosed to the other party in the Affidavit of Documents. While a document is helpful to your case, the court may not allow it to be used. If it is helpful to your opponent's case, the court may order a new trial and order you to pay the costs of the aborted trial.

Please provide your lawyer with all documents relating to your action and a list of all documents that you once had but are no longer in your possession. You need not worry if they are privileged or not. That determination will be made by us.

TOP OF PAGE


How to be a Trial Witness
It is understandable to be nervous when asked to testify in court. By learning more about the trial process, most people gain confidence and become much better witnesses.

Where do I go?
If you are a party to the lawsuit, come to our office on court day. Court usually begins at 10:00 a.m. Be sure to arrive no later than 9:30 a.m.

If you are a non-party witness (i.e. not a direct litigant), you may be excluded from the courtroom until you are called to testify. Contact our office for the location of the courtroom and for the approximate time that you will be called to testify. Because of the nature of trials, we cannot always determine when you will be called. Stay in touch with our office for timely information.

What to wear?
Men should wear a business suit or suitable casual attire (not jeans or a tee shirt!). Women should also wear proper attire. Do not wear bright colours or accessories. A court is a solemn place and your attire should be appropriate for the occasion. Remember to turn off all cellular phones and pagers before going into the courtroom.

Do I have to swear an oath?
You must either swear on a religious book or, if you are not religious, make a solemn affirmation to tell the truth.

What do I do if the judge asks a question?
Listen carefully to the question. Address the judge as 'Your Honour'.

How should I prepare for the testimony?

Read over any witness statement or chronology which you may have made earlier in the proceeding. If you were examined for discovery (a pre-trial examination where the opposing lawyer asks questions of you under oath), read the transcript carefully before you are called to testify at trial. The opposing lawyer may try to elicit statements from you on cross-examination that will contradict your previous testimony. We will, of course, meet with you to prepare you to testify.

What tips do you have about how to make the best impression on the judge?
Judges are human beings like the rest of us. They are influenced by things such as the conviction of the speaker as well as clarity and consistency of the testimony. The best advice is to be yourself and answer directly and honestly.

Most cases involve disputed facts. The judge decides whose version of the facts is more accurate. They do this by assessing each witness's credibility - who is telling the truth and who is not. If a judge decides that a witness has no credibility, then most of that person's testimony will be discarded. On occasion, witnesses will think that they are helping their case by giving clever answers or half-truths instead of direct answers. Judges are very experienced in spotting this sort of behaviour. Often they will say nothing until the trial is over, but will surely take it into account in rendering judgment.
Some of the signposts judges look for when assessing the credibility of a witness:













Answers that sound rehearsed.
Witnesses who are 'difficult' over obvious points. Example:
Cross examiner: You will agree that it is important to read a document before you sign it?
Witness: No.
Cross examiner: You do not think that this is important?
Witness: No.
Answers that the witness thinks will help his case, instead of a straightforward, honest answer. Consider this excerpt from a judgment in an actual case: "I am of the view that the witness on occasion lied to the court and very frequently demonstrated that the evidence he gave was adjusted to fit his conclusions rather than the actual facts."
Disrespect to the opposing lawyer or the court.
An argumentative or overly combative attitude during cross-examination.

Emotions
Testifying can often be stressful and emotional for witnesses. Most lawyers agree that witnesses are more effective when they do not let their emotions rule them when being examined or cross-examined. Certainly, it is best not to show hostility when being cross-examined by the opposing lawyer. Emotions can throw witnesses off balance so that they do not say what they intend. In fact, some lawyers will try to encourage a witness to show anger for this very reason.

What should I tell the people who come to court with me?
Courts are open to the public. Remind them however that the judge can see everything in the courtroom. Your friends and family should be told not to talk while court is in session, chew gum, laugh or show disrespect to the other side or the opposing lawyer. Remember to turn off all cellular phones and pagers before going into the courtroom.

Before you testify you will be prepared by our lawyers. If you follow these suggestions you will be a confident and prepared witness.

TOP OF PAGE


Pre-trial Conferences
A pre-trial or settlement conference is a meeting held between the solicitors for both the plaintiff, the defendant and a judge. This meeting is held after the matter has been listed for trial and one of the parties has informed the court that the case is ready for trial.

Purposes of Conference
One of the purposes of the pre-trial or settlement conference is to facilitate a settlement of the dispute. In preparation for the meeting, lawyers for all parties are expected to canvass settlement options. At the meeting, the judge reviews the options and tries to facilitate a resolution of the dispute. Although some judges encourage the parties themselves to attend the meeting, most do not. Most judges feel that the settlement discussions will flow more freely if the parties are not present.
If a settlement is not possible, then the judge converts the meeting into a trial management meeting and tries, with the assistance of counsel, to:







simplify the issues in the action
consider the possibility of obtaining admissions from either party that will shorten the trial
estimate the length of the trial
consider whether the court should appoint an expert to assist the court regarding any special or technical issues
consider any matters that may help the action be disposed of in the speediest, least expensive, and fairest manner.

The pre-trial judge will not be the trial judge. Nothing discussed at a pre-trial can be disclosed to the trial judge. Parties are expected to keep everything discussed at the pre-trial or settlement conference confidential.

Costs of attendance at a pre-trial or settlement conference are usually assessed as part of the costs of the action itself.

TOP OF PAGE

   
   Sotos LLP 180 Dundas St. W., Ste. 1250 • Toronto ON Canada • M5G 1Z8 • t ) 416.977.0007